Drilling into the comparison

The landing grid answers who. None of these answers that again — each answers a question the grid raises and then cannot follow up.

Central Defender, the seeded role, sixteen weighted attributes. Harry Maguire's figures are real, read off his own drawer, and the arithmetic below reproduces the 72 the app shows him. The other five carry their real ATTRIBUTE SCORES from the same screenshot; the per-attribute spread behind each is illustrative, because that is not on screen anywhere to copy.

The grid as it stands

A — Where each score comes from

Every bar is the score, taken apart. A segment is weight × share, so the whole bar IS the arithmetic rather than a picture of it. Grouped by category, because sixteen segments is not a thing anybody reads.

B — Why he is above him

C — One column, everybody

What this settles